The Never Ending Pool

QUOTE:
See my response in bold within the text

b]Warren wrote:[/b]

QUOTE:
Littlesadie wrote:

QUOTE:
Warren wrote:

QUOTE:
.
Littlesadie wrote:

QUOTE:
Warren wrote:

QUOTE:
.
Littlesadie wrote:

QUOTE:
[...]but, what, exactly, did she say that wasn't true?

Then there's this post by none other than double ee in the Comments at americansongwriter.com:

so what did she say was untrue?


http://www.americansongwriter.com/2010/04/joni-mitchell-slanders-bob-dylan/


Priceless.

Either quote me or don't quote me Warren, but don't quote me half assed when you can do it whole assed.

See my post in bold

I trust that by "half assed" you actually mean, partially. I'll quote you or anyone else as I see fit, "Littlesadie." If you had paid attention instead of being so trigger-happy, you would have noted that I inserted an elipsis inside square brackets to indicate that I wasn't quoting you completely. I didn't quote you completely because whatever else you said was not germane to my point.

What you selectively lopped off was substantial to my position on the subject and very relevant. It was to stress my appreciation for the man's body of work, but that there were also questionable things. Good lord knows I'd be pointed at for Bob bashing which was not my intent and what I posted was important to that point. To selectively extract what you want out of context to make some point on your position is half-assed.

QUOTE:
No one has yet been able to say how on this forum yet.

How what?

How she was wrong.

QUOTE:
Just because one article's headline uses the word 'slander' doesn't necessarily make it so.

I have no idea what you are talking about.

The specific article you linked says this: http://www.americansongwriter.com/2010/04/joni-mitchell-slanders-bob-dylan/

Which, in what may be my fault, was an assumption of a point you were trying to make.

QUOTE:
Tell us, Warren, why do you think she's wrong in what she says. Rip that article apart and HER quotes and tell us why.

Did I say she was wrong in what she said? I didn't say a thing one way or the other about her!

That is correct Warren, as I stated what was it you contributed to the thread topic and not to the poster in it? (As, apparently, with this post you are claiming you said nothing about Joni's remarks). Except to link an article that has been written 6 different ways to Sunday and read by anyone posting in here already and posted in the first post of this thread.

QUOTE:
You've contributed nothing here except to quote half assed and re-quote an article that's already been posted in several places and read.

I did not re-quote an article. I provided a link to substantiate a claim that I made.

What claim? You just stated you made no point either way.

QUOTE:
So, are you here to contribute or just attempt to stir a pot again where no problem exists?

Attempt? I kinda get the feeling that I succeeded. :)

At what?

QUOTE:
What are YOUR opinions on what SHE said?

I haven't yet formulated one. Sorry.

Your original post makes absolutely no sense to me and this post doesn't really make any more sense of it. When you do formulate an opinion, I think everyone would be happy to hear it.